From 7f0e765cf9243d7d415078007ebc41c40fb62ac9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Mary Anthony Introduce yourself, and share a little about your app, the team and story behind it. You want it to give an overview that Stack’s token holders wouldn’t be able to get elsewhere, but also make sure to keep it concise and to the point. Leverage Markdown. You can post links, images and videos. Make sure to add social media links that can point out how actively you are promoting your app, and - with the caveat that all conversations are public - feel free to share your own contact information as well. This is basic, but some App Founders forget it: don’t leave questions unanswered. Every question is an opportunity to engage
- voters and share more about your work, and a thoughtful answer can be the beginning of a closer relationship with a Stacks token holder. Welcome positive and negative feedback equally - both are intended for your growth!
-
-
-
-Democracy Earth is constantly iterating to make vote.blockstack.org a better tool. If you have any feedback, please share with appmining@democracy.earth.
-
## Recommendations from Product Hunt
### Product Hunt Community Score
diff --git a/_data/appFAQ.json b/_data/appFAQ.json
index 8b0c24f9..87ba00a2 100644
--- a/_data/appFAQ.json
+++ b/_data/appFAQ.json
@@ -16,10 +16,10 @@
expect will evolve and improve over time. We look forward to feedback from our
community regarding the App Mining process and program.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
App mining results are sent to Blockstack by app reviewer partners.
Blockstack team performs App Mining algorithm as referenced here.
App mining results are sent to Blockstack by app reviewer partners.
Blockstack team performs App Mining algorithm as referenced here.
The following calendar shows events each month related to App Mining:
" @@ -83,18 +83,10 @@ out our Ruby on Rails gem." }, { + "category":"appminers", "question":"Who are the app reviewers?", - "answer": "App reviewers are currently selected by Blockstack PBC. Reviewers are - entities that have a proprietary methodology that helps them make objective - judgements for why a certain app might be better than others. We strive to - engage a diverse coalition of app reviewers with the goal of making application - ranking objective and resilient to abuse.
As of January 2019, the reviewers were: - Product Hunt, Try My UI and Democracy Earth (who - uses software to collect votes by Stacks token holders). See here - for more details about each reviewer. Future reviewers could - expand to community election. Please see our github - repository to raise issues or make suggestions for App Mining.
" - }, + "answer":"App reviewers are currently selected by Blockstack PBC. Reviewers are entities that have a proprietary methodology that helps them make objective judgements for why a certain app might be better than others. We strive to engage a diverse coalition of app reviewers with the goal of making application ranking objective and resilient to abuse.
The app reviewers are Product Hunt, TryMyUI, Awario, and the digital rights reviewer. See here for more details about each reviewer. Future reviewers could expand to community election. Please see our GitHub repository to raise issues or make suggestions for App Mining.
" + }, { "question":"How are apps ranked?", "answer": "App reviewers have a proprietary methodology that helps them make @@ -124,10 +116,6 @@ your app in a past month, as long as you are in the 6 month time window you will not have to Hunt the app.
" }, - { - "question":"Can developers engage with voters on Democracy Earth?", - "answer": "Yes, they can. App miners can and should create an account on Democracy Earth. From this account they can engage with voters through the debate feature. Learn more in the documentation.
" - }, { "question":"When are the winning payments made?", "answer": "Payouts are made on the 15th of every month.
" diff --git a/_data/navigation_learn.yml b/_data/navigation_learn.yml index 54224ae1..7ed4ed18 100644 --- a/_data/navigation_learn.yml +++ b/_data/navigation_learn.yml @@ -35,7 +35,6 @@ - develop/mining_intro - develop/app-reviewers - develop/mining_enroll - - develop/vote-blockstack - community/app-miners-guide - develop/appMiningFAQ diff --git a/_data/theFAQs.json b/_data/theFAQs.json index 7dff3abd..5c4ce6b5 100644 --- a/_data/theFAQs.json +++ b/_data/theFAQs.json @@ -258,7 +258,7 @@ { "category":"appminers", "question":"What is the App Mining timeline?", - "answer":"App mining results are sent to Blockstack by app reviewer partners.
Blockstack team performs App Mining algorithm as referenced here.
App mining results are sent to Blockstack by app reviewer partners.
Blockstack team performs App Mining algorithm as referenced here.
App reviewers are currently selected by Blockstack PBC. Reviewers are entities that have a proprietary methodology that helps them make objective judgements for why a certain app might be better than others. We strive to engage a diverse coalition of app reviewers with the goal of making application ranking objective and resilient to abuse.
As of January 2019, the reviewers were: Product Hunt, Try My UI and Democracy Earth (who uses software to collect votes by Stacks token holders). See here for more details about each reviewer. Future reviewers could expand to community election. Please see our GitHub repository to raise issues or make suggestions for App Mining.
" + "answer":"App reviewers are currently selected by Blockstack PBC. Reviewers are entities that have a proprietary methodology that helps them make objective judgements for why a certain app might be better than others. We strive to engage a diverse coalition of app reviewers with the goal of making application ranking objective and resilient to abuse.
The app reviewers are Product Hunt, TryMyUI, Awario, and the digital rights reviewer. See here for more details about each reviewer. Future reviewers could expand to community election. Please see our GitHub repository to raise issues or make suggestions for App Mining.
" }, { "category":"appminers", @@ -330,21 +330,11 @@ "question":"Do I have to Hunt my app on Product Hunt?", "answer":"As part of the ranking process, there is an assessment by App Reviewer Product Hunt via their community vote and their internal team vote. More info on the algorithm, here. The Hunt launch will have an impact on your final ranking, as you can see in the algorithm breakdown. Here is more info on Product Hunt launch best practices. In general, sharing and responsiveness to questions are encouraged, and it might help your community reception if you choose to hunt the app yourself. If not, Product Hunt can hunt your App as well.
Apps will be hunted every 6 months, so if you hunted your app in a past month, as long as you are in the 6 month time window, you will not have to Hunt the app.
" }, - { - "category":"appminers", - "question":"Can developers engage with voters on Democracy Earth?", - "answer":"Yes, they can. App miners can and should create an account on Democracy Earth. From this account, they can engage with voters through the debate feature. Learn more in the documentation.
" - }, { "category":"appminers", "question":"When are the winning payments made?", "answer":"Payouts are made on the 15th of every month.
" }, - { - "category":"appminers", - "question":"What’s the incentive for user voting? ", - "answer":"Voters in the App Mining ecosystem use Democracy Earth to vote for applications. Voters are currently Stacks token holders with incentive to strategically allocate resources in the ecosystem to apps they consider highly valuable.
" - }, { "category":"appminers", "question":"What are examples of any quantitative metrics that may be shared with app reviewers?", diff --git a/_develop/app-reviewers.md b/_develop/app-reviewers.md index bd025e49..66daa03f 100644 --- a/_develop/app-reviewers.md +++ b/_develop/app-reviewers.md @@ -16,26 +16,6 @@ Product Hunt is the place to find the best new products in tech. They have a mas Their community score is determined only by the number of **credible** upvotes an app received on Product Hunt, relative to other apps that are registered. For example, if an app got more upvotes than any other app in a cohort, their community score would be 100. If a different app got 60% as many upvotes, they’d get a score of 60. Blockstack converts these scores into *z-scores*. - -## Democracy Earth - -Democracy Earth is a platform for borderless peer-to-peer democracy. They’ve -built a platform that anyone can use to gather votes in a trust-less, -decentralized way. - -Democracy Earth has built a platform for Stacks token holders to vote on how -apps should be ranked. Each token holder gets a 1000 votes, and they can -distribute those votes however they want. It’s possible to give all of your -votes to a single app, and you can also “downvote” an app with one of your -votes. - -After a voting period, each app has a certain amount of upvotes and downvotes. -First, Democracy Earth calculates the percentage of total votes that are -upvotes. If an app receives 90 upvotes and ten downvotes, the resulting -“likability score” is 90. Secondly, Democracy Earth calculates a “traction -score," which ranks how many total votes (including downvotes) an app received, -relative to other apps. - ## Digital Rights Reviewer As a "digital rights reviewer," New Internet Labs reviews apps submitted to the app mining program based on the degree to which the apps respect and protect users` fundamental digital rights. For these review, the use of Blockstack Auth and Blockstack IDs are evaluated. The reviewer checks if Blockstack Auth is: diff --git a/_develop/mining_intro.md b/_develop/mining_intro.md index a952fca9..e878b2e5 100644 --- a/_develop/mining_intro.md +++ b/_develop/mining_intro.md @@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ Blockstack worked with a team of Ph.D. game theorist and economists from Princeton and NYU to put together a [ranking algorithm](https://blog.blockstack.org/app-mining-game-theory-algorithm-design/) which is fair and resistant to abuse. Blockstack uses the third-party -reviewers: Product Hunt, Awario, TryMyUI, and Democracy.earth. These reviewers are +reviewers: Product Hunt, Awario, TryMyUI, and Democracy.. These reviewers are independent, and generally rely on their own proprietary data and insights to generate rankings. @@ -33,9 +33,9 @@ and 100 for the following: * Product Hunt community score * Product Hunt team score -* Democracy Earth likability score -* Democracy Earth traction score * TryMyUI ALF score +* Awario +* digital rights review First Blockstack's determine a ‘z-score’ for each ranking category community, team, likability, and traction. This is a statistical technique to account for diff --git a/_develop/vote-blockstack.md b/_develop/vote-blockstack.md deleted file mode 100644 index bbaa7987..00000000 --- a/_develop/vote-blockstack.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,214 +0,0 @@ ---- -layout: learn -permalink: /:collection/:path.html ---- -# Use the Democracy Earth voting process -{:.no_toc} - -Democracy Earth developed the `vote.blockstack.org` site for voting on applications in the App Mining program. The votes cast through Democracy Earth are consumed by App Mining's ranking algorithm and so affect the final ranking of applications each month. - -Democracy Earth is a platform for borderless peer-to-peer democracy. Every aspect of `vote.blockstack.org` is thoughtfully designed with an understanding that governance is about enabling rich exchanges of information. The goal is to surface the optimal collective intelligence of a network. - -This page details information related to the voting process and participation rules and contains the following topics: - -* TOC -{:toc} - -## Understand the voting process - -Two categories of people participate in the voting process. Application miners who have submitted their application for mining are one category. The other people in the process are Stacks token holders who have asked Blockstack for voting privileges. Stacks token holders vote applications up or down; miners respond to questions about their applications. - -{% include important.html content="Blockstack may ask token holders to become voters or token holders may request an invitation to vote. If you are a token holder and would like to become a voter, email mining@app.co for more information. Of course, token holders that are also application miners are not eligible to vote." %} - -The following video provides a short, visual introduction to Democracy Earth and the voting process: - - - - - -### The value of a vote - -When token holders accept the voter responsibility and become a voter, they -receive 1000 lifetime votes. App Mining rewards are distributed every month at -the end of the month. So, voters must vote each month before the distribution. -You can expect to review and vote between the start and end of each month. - -Votes are a valuable resource. They ultimately help shape the future of blockchain development by directing financial support to innovative development efforts. As a voter, you are expected to review each application and speak with the app developers. This evaluation is similar to the evaluation process of any early-stage angel investor. - -After evaluating applications, you can distribute some or all of your 1000 -votes. You distribute votes by voting an application either up (approval) or -down (disapproval). You can take votes you bestowed the previous month on one -application and give them to another. Of course, if none of the applications are -up to your standards, you can abstain from voting entirely that month. - - -### How app miners participate - -Choosing how to allocate votes for a monthly payout of 100k is not a trivial task. To help voters learn more, each app has a **Debate** section where voters and app miners can interact with each other. Questioning and constructive feedback are enormously insightful input for app miners. - - - -Voters are encouraged to inquire and provide feedback as much as possible. - -Similarly, app miners are encouraged to introduce themselves, explain their goals, their applications, and share more about their work. Remember, everyone's joint goal is to build an application ecosystem where all users control their data. - - -### When voting occurs - -New applications are added to Democracy Earth at the start of every month. All new apps added to Democracy Earth are highlighted with a **New** badge so voters can easily spot them. - - - -Apps from a previous month remain eligible for voting. This means the pool of applications expands each month. The reason for this is that applications are evolving products, they evolve the quality or expand their features. A product you thought wasn't so good could make a giant leap forward from one month to the next. Applications appear in a randomized order so all can receive equal attention from voters. - -Every month, all voters receive a newsletter with updates related to App Mining's vote. The newsletter contains additional timing-related reminders. If you are a voter make sure you add appmining@democracy.earth to your contacts list. This prevents the newsletter from going to your Spam folder. - -Use the platform to talk (debate) to application miners and to vote on applications. At the 15th of ever month, votes are tabulated. - - -### About vote tabulation - -Once a vote is cast, the vote goes onto the ledger for that app. It stays on the application until you remove it by reallocating the vote. At the end of every monthly cycle, each application has a certain amount of upvotes and downvotes. - -Blockstack uses votes to calculate a _likability score_ and a _traction score_ for each app. For example, an app with 90 up- and 10 down-votes has a likability score of 80. A traction score ranks how many total votes (including downvotes) an app received, relative to other apps. Both scores are inputs into the ranking algorithm used by App Mining. - - -## Create a voter or app miner profile on Democracy Earth - -Both voters and an application miners create a profile on Democracy Earth's `vote.blockstack.org` site. Participation on the site is controlled by the email in your Democracy Earth profile; so the email you use matters. Your profile needs to use a specific email: - -You are | -Email to use | -
---|---|
voter | -Use the same email you use when communicating with Blockstack about your tokens. | -
app miner | -Use the email you provided when submitting your application to App Mining (app.co site). | -